From ?????, Age 14 - 10/17/04 - IP#: 24.60.88.xxx  Click here to reply  
would u consider me really fat im 5'8 185
Reply from Kaitlyn, Age 15 - 10/18/04  - IP#: 216.74.216.xxx
Ya i'm 5'7 and 177 but some people say I weight 150, I'm like sweet! Ya, but your not fat, maybe overweight, but that doesn't make us fat!!!
 
Reply from shadow_plauge, Age 15 - 10/18/04  - IP#: 64.6.46.xxx
Well it really much depends on where exactly you carry you weight. I personally, wouldn't think you're really fat at all. Especially since, well my sister is 5'5 and weighs 181 but she fakes it for a person who weighs at 150 really good. I suppose it is because not all of her weight is fat, but muscle too. Well the BMI chart says your BMI is 28.1 and usually it "should" be 24.9 for that you would have to weigh, according to your height around 158.